CORRELATION AND STRATA: FINDASAURUS
BACKGROUND INFORMATIONONE WAY to find out more information about dinosaurs is to discover more dinosaur fossils. The type of rocks in which dinosaur fossils (and almost all other fossils) are found is called sedimentary rock. Sedimentary rock generally occurs as flat layers called strata (single layers called stratum). Imagine you have a handful of both coarse and very fine sand and a bucket of water. If you were to drop the sand into the water two things would happen. First, the sand would settle to the bottom of the bucket. The coarse sand would settle faster and then the fine sand would slowly settle out. Secondly, when the sand reached the bottom of the bucket it would spread out forming two flat layers, a layer of coarse sand covered by the layer of fine sand. The process of settling is called sedimentation from the Latin, sedimentum, meaning the act of settling. The layers formed across the bottom of the bucket are called strata, from the Latin word stratum, meaning covering.
Virtually the identical process occurs in nature. Imagine a river carrying lots of sand and other material worn from rocks emptying into a large body of water like a lake or ocean. Flat layers are created on the bottom of the body of water. Dinosaur bones carried by the river would also settle out and be found in one of the layers on the lake or ocean bottom. Eventually it would be covered by subsequent layers. Over time, the soft layers would be turned into rock, the bones would be preserved within the layers, and finally they might be raised to the surface where a lucky paleontologist might recover them for a museum.
Looking for bone layers is much like playing detective. Using 4.6 billion years as the age of the Earth and 164 million years for the tenure of dinosaurs on the planet, it is easy to determine that dinosaurs existed on Earth for only a very short part of the Earth's history (only 3.6% of the time). Holmes (see References below) lists a maximum total thickness of 452,000 feet of rocks that are known to contain fossils of animals with hard parts; only 125, 000 feet of which were deposited when the dinosaurs existed. If only 28% of the fossil-bearing rock thickness may contain dinosaur fossils, how do we search for them?
The first thing we must do is narrow the search. We must first locate the 28% of sedimentary
rocks in which dinosaur fossils may be found. Let's consider an ideal situation. A
paleontologist from Texas went on vacation to Montana where he discovered dinosaur bones
in a particular layer of rock. He wondered if the same layer existed in Texas so he could find
bones closer to his home. If that particular rock layer appeared on the Earth's surface,
continuously, all the way from Montana to Texas he would be able to walk along the layer to
follow it. That would be easy, but, unfortunately, the easy way never seems to work. In many
cases the bone layer would be covered by layers of younger rocks, and in other cases the bone
layer could be worn away by erosion. Both covering and erosion would make it impossible to
follow the layer from Montana to Texas. Clearly, another method must be found. One of the
most reliable ways to locate fossils is with other fossils. Certain widely found fossils
represent animals that only lived on Earth for a very short time. Such fossils are called index
fossils. When found in two geographically separated layers, they allow scientists to say, with
some confidence, the layers are the same. Index fossils can be used to track a layer from
Montana to Texas, or from Montana to France. The process of determining if layers in
different places are the same is called correlation.
Once the layer is found, more work needs to be done. Dinosaurs probably did not live everywhere in that layer. We know that dinosaurs did not live in the oceans. We can avoid searching in areas that fossils tell us were oceans at the time of the dinosaurs. Fish and marine reptiles (such as plesiosaurs) did not live in the same places as dinosaurs. If paleontologis ts find the former, they won't find the latter. Index fossils allow us to not only determine what layers contain other fossils, but also where in that layer certain fossils may be found.
ACTIVITY: FINDASAURUSUsing fossils to correlate and locate the correct strata, and to determine where in those strata dinosaurs might be found, it is now possible to see how dinosaur fossils can be traced from one place to another.
Time: 30-45 minutes
MATERIALS drawing pencil with eraser
2 colored pencils
copies of Figures 1 and 2 for each student
overhead transparency of Figures 1 and 3
DIRECTIONS1) Distribute Figure 1 to students. Explain that the figures show two stacks of rock layers, one in Montana and one in France. Their job is to determine: a. Which layers (strata) in Montana correlate with (are the same as the) strata in France (by matching letters), b. Which layer in France contains the same dinosaur fossil as layer "d" in Montana.
2) Using one of their colored pencils ask students to connect the borders of the rock layers in Montana with those in France. Use the transparency to model one connection for the class. Students will often be reluctant to make connections because of the uncertainty involved; they do not want to make a wrong connection. Explain that is what happens to scientists also. The connection they draw now is called a hypothesis, or a best guess. Will it be correct? Probably not, but that's all right. Once they add the information from the fossils (soon to follow) they can see if they were on the right track. On the back of Figure 1, ask students to write the letter of the layer in France they predict will contain the dinosaur bone found in layer "d" in Montana.
3) Distribute Figure 2 to students. Figure 2 is a
chart showing index fossils found in certain layers. Each fossil will be found in only one
layer in Montana and only one layer in France. That is how the students will determine how
the strata correlate. Using their drawing pencils and the information shown in Figure 2, students should draw the fossils in the layers shown on the
chart. For instance, index fossil number 2 should be drawn only in
layers c and i. Students should make their best efforts at reproducing the drawing accurately,
but they should also be made aware they will not be judged on their drawings. The drawings,
like the fossils, are clues to help them determine how the layers correlate; they are not pieces
of artwork. Only one fossil will be drawn in each space. Time to complete this part should be
flexible, depending upon the skill levels of the students.
Using a colored pencil different from that used in direction 2, ask students to now connect the layers using the fossil evidence they have just drawn. Have them compare these connections with those made in direction 2. How close did they come? Which ones do they think are most accurate? Why?
4) Which layer in France do they now believe contains the dinosaur fossil? (should be "j.") Is it the same as the one they guessed earlier? What was the clue that made the biggest difference?
5) Once students have completed their efforts, show them the transparency of the solution, Figure 3.
REFERENCESHolmes, Arthur. Principles of Physical Geology. New York: Ronald Press, 1965.
Return to top